Hacker News with Generative AI: Antitrust

Y Combinator says Google is a monopolist, no comment about its OpenAI ties (techcrunch.com)
Fabled startup investor and accelerator Y Combinator has some choice words for Google in an amicus brief it just submitted in the U.S.’s monopoly case against the search giant.
Google Search Engineer Rants on DOJ's Anti-Trust Case (seroundtable.com)
Ryan Moulton, a Google Search engineer who works on Google's search rankings algorithms for over 18 years now, went to X to call out some of what the courts are saying as not true.
Google Facing at Least €12B in Civil Claims Across Europe (bloomberg.com)
Alphabet Inc.’s Google is facing at least €12 billion in damage claims from dozens of price comparison websites across the European Union which allege that the search and advertising giant stole their customers, according to a Bloomberg News review.
Senators probe Google–Anthropic, Microsoft–OpenAI deals over antitrust concerns (computerworld.com)
Democratic Senators Elizabeth Warren and Ron Wyden have launched a formal inquiry into partnerships between tech giants Google and Microsoft, and AI startups, demanding detailed information about arrangements they fear may be circumventing antitrust scrutiny while consolidating power in the rapidly evolving AI market.
US vs. Google amicus curiae brief of Y Combinator in support of plaintiffs [pdf] (courtlistener.com)
DOJ's extreme proposals will hurt consumers and America's tech leadership (google)
The remedies hearing in the Department of Justice’s case against Google Search wrapped up this week. We have been posting summaries week by week:
If Google is forced to give up Chrome, what happens next? (theregister.com)
When Donald Trump entered the White House, I expect Google thought its worries were over. A million-dollar "donation" for the inaugural ball, some face time between Sundar Pichai and Trump, and President Joe Biden's pesky Department of Justice (DoJ) demanding Google divest itself of its Chrome web browser would all be forgotten.
Apple: "millions to billions" lost without App Store commissions (arstechnica.com)
Apple is moving quickly to shut the external payments door opened by last week's ruling that the company willfully failed to comply with court orders regarding anticompetitive behavior.
Consumer Watchdog Halts Google Payment Supervision (bloomberg.com)
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau discontinued its order designating the supervision of Alphabet Inc.’s Google Payment Corp., reversing a Biden-era decision to monitor the nonbank financial platform.
Meta faces lawsuit that could dismantle it (unionrayo.com)
Goodbye to the old Facebook - Zuckerberg admits he no longer connects family and friends, faces FTC lawsuit that could dismantle Meta
DoJ confirms it wants to break up Google ad business (arstechnica.com)
The advertising remedy trial will begin on September 22.
Firefox could be doomed without Google search deal, says executive (theverge.com)
Firefox could be put out of business should a court implement all the Justice Department’s proposals to restrict Google’s search monopoly, an executive for the browser owner Mozilla testified Friday.
DOJ confirms it wants to break up Google's ad business (arstechnica.com)
The advertising remedy trial will begin on September 22.
US asks judge to break up Google's ad tech business after requesting Chrome sale (theguardian.com)
Google on Friday faced a demand by the US government to break up its hugely profitable ad technology business. The request came after a judge found the tech giant was commanding an illegal monopoly for the second time in less than a year.
Firefox could be doomed without Google search deal, says executive (theverge.com)
Firefox could be put out of business should a court implement all the Justice Department’s proposals to restrict Google’s search monopoly, an executive for the browser owner Mozilla testified Friday.
Judge Rules Apple Violated Court Order on App Store Anti-Steering Provisions (daringfireball.net)
Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers Rules, in Excoriating Decision, That Apple Violated Her 2021 Court Order Regarding App Store Anti-Steering Provisions
A judge just blew up Apple's control of the App Store (theverge.com)
The judge in Epic v. Apple has banned Apple from charging a commission on purchases made outside the App Store because of its ongoing anticompetitive behavior.
Is Chrome Even a Sellable Asset? (daringfireball.net)
There are two ways to consider a forced divestiture of Chrome by Google, as the U.S. Department of Justice has, for months now, been requesting after Judge Amit P. Mehta ruled that Google has illegally maintained its monopoly in web search. One is from a business perspective (which I believe is the only perspective considered by the DOJ). The other is from a technical perspective. I don’t think either makes any sense.
All four major web browsers are about to lose 80% of their funding (medium.com)
Four major web browsers dominate the market: Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge, Mozilla Firefox, and Apple’s Safari. What most users don’t realize is that Google effectively bankrolls over 80% of the development for all of them. But this funding stream is under threat: the US Department of Justice is moving to force Google to cut off its competitors and divest from Chrome, a decision that will simultaneously cripple the development of every major browser.
Don't make Google sell Chrome (world.hey.com)
The web will be far worse off if Google is forced to sell Chrome, even if it's to atone for legitimate ad-market monopoly abuses.
Mark Zuckerberg personally lost the Facebook antitrust case (pluralistic.net)
It's damned hard to prove an antitrust case: so often, the prosecution has to prove that the company intended to crush competition, and/or that they raised prices or reduced quality because they knew they didn't have to fear competitors.
Jedi Blue (wikipedia.org)
Jedi Blue is an agreement between Alphabet and Meta Platforms that allegedly gave Facebook an illegal advantage in Google's ad auctions in exchange for Facebook's word that it would end its own ad service plans.
Mark Zuckerberg says social media is over (newyorker.com)
During testimony at Meta’s antitrust trial, the Facebook founder’s argument was, in so many words, that platforms like his are not what they used to be.
OpenAI says it would buy Chrome if Google is forced to sell (engadget.com)
Google is under the microscope following a court ruling last year that it has a monopoly over online search, but the future of its vast suite of digital services is still uncertain at this stage.
Google contract prevented Motorola from setting Perplexity as default assistant (bloomberg.com)
Google’s contract with Lenovo Group Ltd.’s Motorola blocked the smartphone maker from setting Perplexity AI as the default assistant on its new devices, an executive of the startup testified at the search giant’s antitrust trial.
Google reveals sky-high Gemini usage numbers in antitrust case (arstechnica.com)
Google revealed in court that Gemini now sees 350 million monthly users.
Break Google's Search Monopoly Without Breaking the Web (open-web-advocacy.org)
In late 2020, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), in conjunction with state attorneys general representing 11 states, brought a landmark antitrust case against Google for unlawfully maintaining a monopoly in the general search engine market.
OpenAI tells judge it would buy Chrome from Google (theverge.com)
If Google is forced to sell off Chrome, ChatGPT’s head of product told a judge today that OpenAI would be interested in buying the browser, Reuters reports.
Commission Finds Apple and Meta in Breach of the Digital Markets Act (europa.eu)
Apple and Meta fined millions for breaching EU law (yahoo.com)
Apple was fined 500 million euros ($570 million) on Wednesday and Meta 200 million euros, as European Union antitrust regulators handed out the first sanctions under landmark legislation aimed at curbing the power of Big Tech.